on behalf of aloha staff, i apologize we haven’t provided more information publicly sooner.
to get started, here’s some evidence that helps to visually highlight part of the problem with BetterSpades compared to the original voxlap client:
videos recorded on the same host by @Darion and @Nuceto
observe the accuracy and range of shotgun at long-range (80 blocks) in BetterSpades:
https://vimeo.com/622852789
…compared to shotgun in voxlap client at the same distance:
https://vimeo.com/622852792
BS shotgun is also “better” than rifle in voxlap client at this range:
https://vimeo.com/622852713
all of these shots were scoped/zoomed in.
the problem with this evidence, though, is that OpenSpades isn’t included as part of the comparison. for that reason i feel this “evidence” is incomplete because tests should be provided with all three clients in identical environments.
also, keep in mind that is only one small sample. we had many more samples, tests, and discussions about BS issues in staff-only channels over a period of several months prior to banning BS from our arena servers.
by the way, the issues are not only concerning gun damage/spread. world sync consistency is apparently another possible issue, a.k.a. “wall banging,” which seems to be worse than the other clients when it comes to high ping players.
i hope to see more evidence from other staff members provided publicly here soon.
tl;dr: hopefully we can get to the bottom of this issue soon. i’m not happy about BetterSpades being banned from arena servers. i think most of us feel that way. all i can ask is that you be patient as we figure this out and help to bring BS back to arena servers sooner than later.
this a complicated and sensitive issue for both BS and non-BS players alike. keep in mind that a significant % of our playerbase uses OpenSpades, and from their perspective BetterSpades is unfairly advantaged. that’s why we’ve chosen to temporarily ban BS from competitive arena servers. according to OS players, the unfair concerns that BS brought to the game have disappeared since banning it from those servers.